This post may contain affiliate links that at no additional cost to you, I may earn a small commission.
Maybelline is NOT Cruelty-Free!
Maybelline allows its products or ingredients to be tested on animals when required by law including when selling in stores in mainland China.
In addition, Maybelline is owned by L’Oreal, a parent company that is also NOT cruelty-free.
Maybelline’s Animal Testing Policy
Maybelline states on its FAQ page that the brand is a subsidiary of L’Oreal. And then continues with L’Oreal’s animal testing policy stating,
“L’Oréal no longer tests any of its products or any of its ingredients on animals, anywhere in the world nor does L’Oréal delegate this task to others. An exception could only be made if regulatory authorities demanded it for safety or regulatory purposes.”
Below is a screenshot of what’s currently stated on Maybelline’s company website:
Unfortunately, L’Oreal (and thereby Maybelline) allows some of their products to be tested on animals when required by law.
Policies stating “an exception could only be made if regulatory authorities demanded it” usually implies the company is selling its products in mainland China. That’s because cosmetics sold in stores in mainland China are required by law to be tested on animals.
Is Maybelline Sold in China?
I found evidence of Maybelline selling its products in China. Below is a screenshot I took from their Chinese website:
But Doesn’t China No Longer Tests on Animals?
Companies can bypass China’s pre-market animal testing by choosing to manufacture their ordinary or general cosmetics in China, but it’s not stated anywhere that Maybelline has taken this route.
Additionally, the possibility of post-market animal testing is not completely ruled out and may be conducted on some cosmetics sold in physical stores in China.
As of May 1, 2021, cosmetic companies can also export and sell their ordinary or general cosmetics in China without animal testing only if they meet a set of preconditions first. However, meeting these conditions has proven difficult, and it’s still unclear what exactly is accepted according to the new regulations. So there’s no word yet of any company that has successfully done so.
Follow the highlighted lines in the graphic below to see why most cosmetics sold in China (like Maybelline and L’Oreal) are still required by law to be tested on animals in 2022.
Because Maybelline has decided to sell in mainland China stores, they must consent and pay to have their products tested on animals. That’s why most cosmetics brands selling in mainland China cannot be considered cruelty-free in 2022.
Although Maybelline may not be conducting these animal tests themselves, they knowingly allow Chinese authorities to test their products on animals to sell in China.
For those reasons, we would not consider Maybelline to be cruelty-free by our standards.
Cruelty-Free Policies
Many truly cruelty-free brands have chosen not to sell their products in China because of its animal testing laws. Unfortunately, Maybelline refuses to do the same and therefore cannot be considered cruelty-free.
At ethical elephant, we always assess a company’s cruelty-free policy using our Cruelty-Free Checklist. This ensures no animal testing was performed by the brand itself, its suppliers, and by any third parties, including when required by law.
See below for our complete cruelty-free checklist. Since Maybelline already does not meet the last two, we cannot classify the brand as being cruelty-free.
Is Maybelline Certified Cruelty-Free?
Maybelline is not certified cruelty-free by any third-party cruelty-free certifications like Leaping Bunny or PETA.
Because Maybelline is not certified cruelty-free by a third party, no one is looking into or substantiating Maybelline’s cruelty-free commitments and claims.
Is Maybelline Owned By A Non-Cruelty-Free Parent Company?
Yes. Maybelline is owned by L’Oreal, a parent corporation that still engages in animal testing in 2022.
Some cruelty-free consumers may choose to purchase and support cruelty-free brands owned by animal-tested parent corporations as they hope it will convince the parent company to go cruelty-free eventually.
But in this case, Maybelline is NOT cruelty-free and neither is its parent corporation, L’Oreal.
Is Maybelline Cruelty-Free?
To sum up, by choosing to sell in mainland China, Maybelline must have its products tested on animals. Therefore, we would NOT consider Maybelline to be a cruelty-free brand.
Currently, Maybelline is on our List of Brands to Avoid – Animal Tested.
Is Maybelline Vegan?
Maybelline has recently been making claims their Green Edition formulas are “vegan” and are made without any animal-derived ingredients. However, since we do not consider Maybelline to be cruelty-free as their products are tested on animals when required by law, we also wouldn’t consider anything sold or manufactured by Maybelline to be vegan.
In order for products to be considered vegan by ethical elephant’s standards, the products and their ingredients must not be tested on animals anywhere in the world. Also, they must not contain any animal-derived ingredients or by-products.
Cruelty-Free Alternatives:
Looking for a cruelty-free alternative to Maybelline? We recommend the following cruelty-free affordable, drugstore makeup brands:
- ELF Cosmetics – 100% Vegan
- Milani – some vegan options
- NYX Cosmetics *owned by L’Oreal – some vegan options
- Essence – some vegan options
- ColourPop – some vegan options
or check out our list of drugstore cruelty-free makeup brands!
20 thoughts on “Maybelline (L’Oreal)”
I am deeply disturbed that in the year 2020, so many cosmetic companies STILL test on animals. With all the knowledge we now have about toxins, carcinogens, etc., I find it unfathomable. I stopped using products tested on animals years ago. Why am I so upset? When talking with others about cosmetics, I invariably get a response like “I’m not giving up my MAC makeup. It’s the best.” And, of course MAC is one of hundreds of brands that still follow this barbaric practice. What should we do? I feel that a majority of consumers prefer to turn a blind eye to what goes on. I might be able to convince a few to purchase only cruelty-free, but until it becomes required across the board to ban animal testing, my hands are tied. I wish we could put a bill before Congress.
Someone didn’t do their due diligence…?
FROM THEIR WEBSITE FAQs:
L’Oréal does not test any of its products or any of its ingredients on animals
Our consumers’ health and safety have always been an absolute priority for L’Oréal. As is the support of animal welfare. L’Oréal does not test any of its products or any of its ingredients on animals and has been at the forefront of alternative methods for over 30 years.
L’Oréal has developed a very rigorous safety evaluation procedure of its products, backed by Research.
Well before the question of animal testing was raised by civil society or within a regulatory framework, L’Oréal has been committed to new methods of assessing safety that don’t involve animals.
A true pioneer, L’Oréal has been reconstructing human skin models in laboratories to elaborate in vitro safety tests since 1979, as an alternative to animals. Since then, L’Oréal has an Episkin center in Lyon (France) Shanghai (China), and Brazil where reconstructed skins are produced.
In addition to skin models, L’Oréal has a large number of non-animal predictive assessment tools, such as molecular modeling, expert toxicology systems, imaging techniques and many more.
L’Oréal has been at the forefront of alternative methods for over 30 years
In 1989, L’Oréal completely ceased testing its products on animals, 14 years before it was required by regulation. Today, L’Oréal no longer tests its ingredients on animals. L’Oréal no longer tolerates any exception to this rule.
Certain health authorities may nevertheless decide to conduct animal tests themselves for certain cosmetic products, as it is still the case in China. L’Oréal is the most active company working alongside the Chinese authorities and scientists for over 10 years to have alternative testing methods recognized, and permit the cosmetic regulation to evolve towards a total and definite elimination of animal testing. Thanks to this, since 2014, certain products manufactured and sold in China like shampoo, body wash or certain make-up products are no longer tested on animals.
Even if regulatory laws in other countries choose to test on animals, the FAQ section HAS been updated since 2015, and it is bad journalism or reporting, or simply lazy to copy and paste information from a previous article, rather than going and finding the most current, updated and accurate information available. This makes all of us who do our best to be cruelty-free and/or vegan appear to be angry and rigid and, above all, too lazy to properly research. I’m incredibly disappointed with your post.
I just checked Maybelline’s FAQ Page (https://www.maybelline.ca/en-ca/faq) and it still says from what I see:
“Animal Testing Policy
Thank you for your interest in Maybelline, a brand of L’Oréal USA, Inc.
L’Oréal no longer tests any of its products or any of its ingredients on animals, anywhere in the world nor does L’Oréal delegate this task to others. An exception could only be made if regulatory authorities demanded it for safety or regulatory purposes.
For complete information on this subject, please click here.”
—
If you see something different, please send me the direct link and I’ll have a look.